I hadn't previously thought of the Boeing F/A-18E/F Super Hornet naval strike fighter as being particularly maneuverable, or particularly good at aerial dogfighting. However, this demonstration by an F/A-18F (the two-seat variant), fully loaded with 8 air-to-air missiles, is pretty convincing. As the pilot points out, it's like flying with a big SUV strapped beneath the aircraft; yet it handles the weight with ease, and he's able to throw it around in cavalier fashion.
Watch the video in full-screen mode for best results.
I'd still put money on an F-15E Strike Eagle to outmaneuver the Super Hornet, but given top-notch pilots in both planes, it'd be a close-run thing.