We all (well, most of us) remember the ominous phrase from George Orwell's novel "1984": "Big Brother is watching you." As the modern "surveillance state" has grown ever more intrusive, many of us have worried about what's left of our privacy. It turns out we effectively don't have any privacy any more, whether we like it or not. State Of Surveillance reports on how advertisements on our cellphones have become tracking beacons, even if we never look at them.
What Actually Happens When an Ad Loads on Your Phone
Open your weather app. Check the forecast. Close the app. In the three seconds that took, your phone just told dozens of companies exactly where you’re standing.
Here’s the chain of events, broken down:
Step 1: The app requests an ad. Your weather app has advertising code baked in, either through the Real-Time Bidding (RTB) system or through a Software Development Kit (SDK) that the app developer embedded for revenue. The moment the app opens, it signals an ad network that it has space to fill.
Step 2: Your data gets broadcast. The ad network fires off what’s called a “bid request” to hundreds or thousands of potential advertisers. That bid request includes your Mobile Advertising ID (MAID), your GPS coordinates, a timestamp, your device type, operating system, the app you’re using, your language settings, and (depending on the SDK) your age, gender, interests, purchase history, Wi-Fi information, and sensor data.
Step 3: The auction happens. Advertisers have roughly 100 milliseconds to decide if they want to bid on your eyeballs. But the bidding is beside the point. Every company that received the bid request now has your location data. Whether they bid or not.
Step 4: The data gets saved. Data brokers participating in this system don’t delete the bid requests. They accumulate them. One broker told Citizen Lab it had data on “more than one billion mobile devices.” Another, collecting through SDKs in 400 apps, claimed 40 million phones.
This entire process takes less than one second. It happens every time an ad loads. On average, your phone does this hundreds of times per day.
How Webloc Turns Ad Data Into a Police Tracking Tool
Penlink (the company that now owns Webloc after acquiring Israeli firm Cobwebs Technologies in 2023) buys this ad auction data in bulk. Billions of daily location signals from hundreds of millions of devices.
Then it builds a product. Government customers get a login. They can:
- Search by phone number, device ID, or advertising ID
- Draw a box on a map and see every device that passed through that area
- Pull location history going back three years
- Identify where someone sleeps (home address), where they work, where they worship, what clinics they visit, and which protests they attend
- Set up continuous monitoring to track a device in near-real time
The system covers up to 500 million mobile devices across more than 30 countries, serviced by 219 active servers: 126 in the U.S., 32 in the Netherlands, and 17 in Singapore.
No warrant required. No judge involved. The Fourth Amendment says the government needs probable cause to track you. The Supreme Court confirmed this in Carpenter v. United States (2018) for cell-site location data. But Webloc skips the phone company entirely. It buys from the advertising industry instead. Different pipeline, same result, no oversight.
There's more at the link.
Remember the recent brouhaha over Flock roadside cameras tracking our vehicles? That seems mild by comparison to this. We've never consented to even a single step in this electronic tracking process, yet it's imposed on us willy-nilly. There's no way to opt out, either.
I'm both furious at this invasion of privacy, and resigned to the fact that if I want to live in the modern world, I have no way of evading or avoiding it. I sometimes think I was born in the wrong century . . .
Peter

It seems like the recourse is to avoid having a phone altogether. Too many of us are dependent on having access to information or others to give them up.
ReplyDeleteTurn off GPS unless you need it. It's not a complete fix, but it makes your location less precise. Remove ad-supported apps. Turn your phone off unless you're using it.
ReplyDeleteAlso, the 4th Amendment jurisprudence is mixed, so blanket statements here are misleading at best. It's so easy to research this. The writer is guilty of intellectual laziness.
- jed
It gets even worse when you consider that many websites and applications consider ad-blocking to be illegal, and will sue for it or prevent access to content.
ReplyDeleteFaraday bag?
ReplyDeleteYou have three choices. Accept the spying, do without a phone altogether or carry an old style flip phone that can only make or receive calls. This would limit the spying but not end it completely. Being old I am NOT depends on cell phones and can function just fine without it. It gets turned on maybe once a week if that.
ReplyDeleteIsn't the practice of 2-factor authentication the exact same thing? By demanding 2 modes of input to access what you already are paying for, they have now pinpointed exactly where you are.
ReplyDeleteSeems to me if you don't use your phone, leave it at home, then you wouldn't have this problem. Generations of meat sock puppets (or whatever the cute saying is these days) never had phones and they survived.
ReplyDeleteNo way to opt out? Sure there are. Use a faraday bag. Turn off your phone. Leave it at home. Etc.
ReplyDeleteAs another commenter said, turn off GPS if you aren't using it and don't use apps that tell on you. I uninstalled the Amazon app after I found it was eavesdropping on my web searches. I also use the Brave browser, it does a decent job blocking ads and cookies.
ReplyDeleteKeep location services off (you can buy an inexpensive phone specifically for Google maps, if needed) use brave mobile browser, use NordVPN, and (optionally, I do because it's free and does a fantastic job blocking in-app ads) configure Adguard DNS.
ReplyDeleteThen go to browserleaks dot com and dnsleaktest dot com, and check for DNS and ipv6 traffic leaks. Also, make sure apps with location permissions are set to only while using, or (like me) just don't use location services at all, except on that inexpensive Google maps phone, which you never pair with your primary phone.
Is it outrageous having to go to these lengths? Yes. But it works. Also, the legality of police etc using webloc is disputed, FWIW. Doesn't make it better that it's an option in the first place, I just wanted to point out that technically it's still not settled that it's okay for them to use it.
Lord have mercy. Christus vincit!
The flock-ers have nothing on the cell phone providers that you pay for service. Rest assured it is the old farm definition of service even if you turn it off. FYI there are reasons your cell phone evolved beyond a removable battery. The only opt out is to go without a cell phone. I am working diligently toward being a free untracked human again soon.
ReplyDeleteCouple years ago son and I were talking about shirts, daughter came over and we had a discussion about an obscure subject and I talked on phone with friend about a restaurant. After each conversation, within 24 hours, I had multiple ad's for everything we had spoken of and in one it was face to face and my phone was in other area of home. They are listening to every word we say 24/7/365.
ReplyDeleteA spectacular fail of the "Jews in the attic test." https://joehuffman.org/Freedom/JewsInTheAttic.htm
ReplyDeleteThis is why the only time my phone was online/5G, when I first bought it. It's a cheap Tracfone, $20/mo. That was about 4 months ago. If I want online I use tablet or computer.
ReplyDeleteThis is the consequence of 'connectivity'...
ReplyDeleteA tablet is not much different than a cell phone. It still identifies your location and id. Modern cars have built in wifi hardware and transmit your location so leaving your phone at home doesn’t enrirely protect you. Databases can correlate all sources of data and easily show your activities in moments.
ReplyDeleteThere's no way to opt out, either. There have been a lot of Comments that say there are. I'll add mine - don't use a cell phone.
ReplyDeleteMy phone stays in the glove box of the truck in a faraday bag. It is for 911 and AAA only. You can call me anything that you want to, just don't try to call me on my phone. ;-)
ReplyDeleteI was just offered a discount on my auto insurance if I installed an app called "Driver IQ". In trying to set it up, it wants to track my location whether or not I'm in a car. No thanks. I just uninstalled it, and I'll forego the discount.
ReplyDeleteI've also been told that turning your phone off is no help either. It'll still track location data, and upload it as soon as it's turned back on. Turn it off, remove the battery (if you can), drop it in a Faraday bag, and you MIGHT prevent it's tracking you.