Coming from Africa as I do, I'd never even heard of ice circles until reaching the USA, and I've still never seen one in the flesh. Nevertheless, this one in Washington state earlier this month certainly looks fascinating. I'm still trying to work out the energy vectors that produce the spinning motion.
There are more images and video clips of the ice circle on the photographer's blog. One day, I'd really like to see one of those for real.
Peter
Water in channels tends to move faster in the center sections, due to less friction from objects and shallows. That should explain the rotation. An ice plate would end up round by shaving it's edges against other objects as it rotates. Notice the debris buildup along the edges of contact with the rest of the ice.
ReplyDeleteThe various elements needed for the situation to develop probably don't occur often enough to make this very common. I suspect the nominal diameter of the ice plate needed is a component of the width of the water channel.
Will is right, and you have 'chunks' hanging down in the current that provide the propulsive moment as the current strikes them.
ReplyDeleteIn Canada, they'd have a keg of Molson's stuck through the ice in the middle of that ice circle, and a bunch of lumberjacks wearing tuques sitting in lawn chairs and finishing off that keg! And every five minutes they'd ring a bell, everyone would jump into the river, swim a lap around the ice circle, then climb back out and scramble for a chair. One of which would have been removed while they were swimming.
ReplyDeleteTHAT is how they play "musical chairs" in Canada, eh?
I saw one once in the Androscoggin,in Northern New Hampshire, at a bend of the river. Must have been at least 100ft in diameter. At that place, in summer, there would have been a huge eddy in the water so the ice spinning did not seem so unusual, it was just doing what the water was doing underneath.
ReplyDeleteSo. Do they spin clockwise in the Southern Hemisphere?
ReplyDelete....Only if they form in the commode. :o
ReplyDeleteI lived in Alaska for 25 years and I never saw or heard if these.
ReplyDeleteI have to like leathernecks idea. I was thinking of the toilet bowl effect there myself.
ReplyDelete