Strategy Page points out that one of the critical underpinnings of the entire Russian economy - much less its war effort - is at the point of catastrophic failure. Yes, Strategy Page tends to be anti-Russian, and as such its objectivity is questionable, but from personal experience (Africa wins again!!!) I can testify that this particular problem rears its head anywhere there's societal entropy.
Russia’s ability to continue the Ukraine war is being compromised due to catastrophic mismanagement of its railway system. This emerging situation is so dire that cutoffs of service to vast areas, starting with Siberia east of Irkutsk to the Bering Sea and Sea of Okhotsk, to save the rest of Russia next year may happen next year. Russian railways account for about 43 percent of all transportation in Russia, and most of its east-west transport. The present rate of loss of rail cars and engines to worn-out axle bearings is so bad that that the Russian economy may come to a standstill and collapse in 1-2 years. One of the key issues here is rail transport of coal, which is declining fast but essential for electric power production.
Running trains with worn-out axle bearings causes them to derail and damage tracks such that movement of trains with effective bearings is not possible until the wrecks are cleared and the rail beds are repaired. Such accidents have recently become significant problems.
The degree of this problem is clouded because the Russian army has taken scores of thousands, perhaps more than a hundred thousand, rail cars out of service for use as storage of their cargos. It takes time and manpower to both unload them for local storage and then reload them for local transport. It’s faster and takes less manpower to unload the rail cars once, directly from the rail cars onto trucks for local delivery. Plus the Ukrainians keep blowing up the unloaded cargo sites ... It is difficult to distinguish rail cars deadlined for worn-out bearings from those with adequate bearings which the Russian army has deadlined as storage for their cargos. Plus there is probably some to considerable overlap between the two.
There's more at the link.
Yes, something as small and as simple as wheel bearings can derail an entire economy. The fact that many of those who maintain and service rail cars have been mobilized and sent to the Ukrainian front in uniform makes it even worse. During World Wars I and II, Britain found it had to de-mobilize critical workers and return them to the factories, because without their skills its economy could not adequately support the war effort. I guess Russia is re-learning that lesson now.
I'd be interested to know how much the problem has been made worse by Russian staff, angry at mobilization hanging over their heads, who've sabotaged rail cars. It's relatively easy to destroy a bearing: just inject something abrasive (metal particles are good, but even ground stone will do in a pinch), along with the grease, to the lubrication nipple on the shaft or wheel bearing. Britain taught Resistance fighters to do this during World War II, and it worked very well. One wonders whether Russian workers (with, perhaps, Ukrainian encouragement) may not be using the same tactic.
Peter
10 comments:
"For want of a nail...."
This touches on something that has been troubling me of late--many, perhaps most, young people simply have no skills. I don't expect them to have the practical skills I developed half a century ago--reading, writing, critical thinking, splitting wood, cooking. What astonishes me is that many of them have not got any new skills that I don't possess. I work with lots of young people, and one task that completely defeats them is using a fillable PDF. I, who never touched a computer until I was almost 40, thinks a fillable PDF one of the great inventions of recent times, but most of the 18 year olds I meet are utterly defeated by them. Why? I suppose it is something similar in Russia, where lubrication is too complex and arcane a skill to master. God help us.
I agree with "The Old Sarge" same thought came to me as well. It is always the little things that mess up the biggest.
"... The fact that many of those who maintain and service rail cars have been mobilized and sent to the Ukrainian front in uniform..."
How was this fact established? I'd be very interested to learn what news organization has such detailed information on the movements and activities of Russian railworkers and maintenance personnel! They must have verifiable numbers, and lists of names and such, if they call it a fact... because if they don't it's not fact, it's speculation and inference.
The good news about this report is that in a couple years we'll be able to say for sure whether strategy page is lying or telling the truth. If the Russian railway system hasn't collapsed by 2027-2028, they're spouting (at best) ignorant propaganda, or (at worst) deliberate deception.
https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1824510358838473080.html Trent Telenko has also written about RU rail logistics and has been spot on.
Just like the Russians ran out of missiles, tanks, aircraft, and artillery shells last year. Out of barrels as well, so even when they import North Korean shells they can't be fired since there are no working artillery pieces.Also that site informs us all the young Russians are dead and the infantry is filled with 60 year olds. Or as another site that links to them put it, the Russians infantry is made up of drunken untrained geriatric conscripts armed only with shovels.
Sites like this do a real disservice by promoting propaganda. Almost everything that happens in Ukraine gets filmed by drones and quickly posted online, by both Ukrainian and Russian units.
I get the value of propaganda to keep political support for keeping the weapons and cash flowing to Ukraine, but so much of it is obviously untrue that I think the damage to credibility far outweighs the benefit of keeping up morale.
No end of bad decisions will be made on the basis of propaganda like these sites post. I can't speak to the ball bearing situation, but so much of everything else sites like this post tend to be wishful thinking.
You could make a long list of similar items for the US economy (and any other economy). There are many items we don't make in the US that would create chaos if the external supply of them was cut off. Chips, transformers, drugs, etc.
Oue infrastructure isn't in much better shape. Greed has made almost all companies postpone or ignore maintenance needs and infrastructure investments. Add in the death of skilled labor that actually knows how to build and fix things and we are in deep trouble, approaching totally screwed.
For going on three years there have been 40-foot container cars idled on sidings throughout northern Minnesota. Not grain cars that are idled until fall, ore cars that are idled during shipping season, but hundreds of BNSF cars that carry two 40-foot overseas shipping containers used for intermodal shipping.
There is a siding just east of Grand Rapids, and yard in Carlton that haven't moved in years.
Good thing the economy is booming.
In addition to Trent Telenko (linked above by Alfred) there's also this person - https://bsky.app/profile/prune602.bsky.social/
Specifically - https://bsky.app/profile/prune602.bsky.social/post/3leah5efetc22 and from the start of the month - https://bsky.app/profile/prune602.bsky.social/post/3lcdewkbmf22w
The Russian economy is not in any way shape or form healthy. The loss of Syria and thus issues connecting to Russian forces looting Africa doesn't help.
See also this Russian (who hates both Ukraine and Putin)
https://alexilex.substack.com/p/my-new-dire-predictions-on-ukrainian
My comment on that post is:
If (2) Economic Collapse happens - and I expect it to unless Putin and Zalensky both accept (1) Trump peace deal really really quickly, which I consider unlikely, and then once accepted sanctions are lifted equally swiftly - then (4) coup is likely to happen too followed by (5) internal Russia civil war and (6) takeover by the PRC of the bits it cares about i.e. Siberia and probably some kind of PRC supported puppet for the Western part of the country as well as independent nations in Chechnya and Dagestan and a greater Ukraine and/or Georgia dominating the rest of the Caucases
I don't particularly want that, but I consider it to be the most likely outcome and it means that Putin will have managed to take a country that was doing fairly well and smash it to pieces.
Post a Comment